Where do I start - I just love this mascara! I have thin, short lashes and I'm in my late 50's. Mascaras just don't work like they used to for me. I've tried almost every brand there is, from dollar store to high end. Almost all of them end up going home with my daughter lol. This, however, I am not giving up! Sheglam Flutterwink Mascara is amazing! It isn't clumpy, it isn't "sloppy". I love the shape of the brush, it gets every little lash! It stays on all day until I wash it off. I do want to say I've used this alone and love it, but when I'm going out and want more of a glam look I layer it with L'Oreal Lash Paradise Primer and the L'Oreal Lash Paradise mascara,, ELF Lash It Loud, and Maybelline Lash Sensational Luscious and wow! My lashes are long and lush and beautiful! The picture doesn't do this combination justice but it was the best I could do with this phone lol