I've been using this for years. I will say that I tried the water-proof version and it was too thick. Super hard to remove as well. This is the best mascara for the price and quality!Been using this brand for a while now. Still like it. Minis come in clutch especially since I don’t use makeup regularly so my mascara doesn’t clump up compared to if I just bought the regular size. Plus it’s cheaper.Petite in size which is great for travel and purse. Excellent mascara. My lashes never look as good as when I use this mascara.Very dry and you only can get a few uses out of each one. Better off buying the large ones.