This is a great mascara. Does not clump or smudge. Removes easily.This mascara is wonderful! So easy to apply and it lengthens and fills out thin, short lashes. The best part is when you remove it; it comes off so easily, unlike some that tear out your lashes!I love this mascara when it is applied. The mascara applies beautifully with no clumps and make my eye lashes looks longer and fuller however, it rubs off waaaayyyy too easily. If i touch my eyes at all i have mascara residue on my hands and around my eyes. Because it does not last as well i have to say it is not worth the price. this is the most expensive mascara i have ever bought and was very disappointed when i realized it does not last.This mascara seems dried out maybe old. Not happy with it. I have used it before and loved it.This is by far one of the best mascaras I’ve ever purchased! I try mostly every mascara that promises any big change because, I have smaller lashes. I’ve brought very high-end and drug store brands. This is in the middle and worth every penny! I normally have to layer several DIFFERENT mascaras to get the look I want as my lashes are short and fade away even more under the weight of my extremely hooded lids. But with this mascara...I don’t have to layer with other brands it does everything I need it to do. It lengthens, adds volumes and is great for a dramatic look that takes you from the corporate or non-profit office to happy hour or to a ball-type setting! This mascara is all you will need for any occasion day or night and will take the tiniest of lashes and allow them to compete with the most longest ones! I love it and I am a life long fan?Love the brush and the ease with which it coats the lashes and keeps them separated. Very little dunking up. However, it does bleed if you laugh or cry. Not heavy but a shadowing and lowered lash skin.First off I loooove Mally brand mascara as a product, works great and I have been using it for years! This review is regarding receiving a broken product. The mascara was greatly priced and I received my package quickly. However, I opened the package excited to replace my older Mally mascara to find a stick missing the eyelash brush. Obviously you can not put on mascara without a brush. Very disappointed, and now I have to spend more money.I ordered this for my daughter. She used to love Mally's volumizing mascara but it has been discontinued so I ordered her this mascara hoping she would like it. I ordered it and she liked it, although not as much as the discontinued one. But the past 2 tubes she has received have gotten dried out and clumpy. Last time she thought maybe she forgot to screw the lid on tight. This most recent tube she got for Christmas and it is already drying and clumping on her.This mascara is absolutely great in my view and when applied with 2 Coates gave me what it says instantly amazing lashesFor an evening and more dramatic look I used a 3rd coat of Mallys more us more mascara on top and mixed the twoDon't need to bother with false lashes for a night out now I have this product